اندیشمند بزرگترین احساسش عشق است و هر عملش با خرد

Thursday, January 16, 2025

The Gaza ceasefire will not cure the wounds of genocide

Roaa Shamallakh
Now that a ceasefire has been agreed to in Gaza, the bombs will stop falling, and the world will breathe a sigh of relief. There will be celebrations of peace, even if temporary, nations will pat themselves on the back, and the media will move on to the next trending crisis. Yet, for those of us who survived, the war hasn’t ended—it has merely transformed. 
 Relatives of the Palestinians killed in Israeli attacks perform funeral prayer after their beloved ones are brought to the al-Ahli Baptist Hospital in Gaza City, on December 17, 2024. (Photo: Hadi Daoud/APA Images)
For us, the war began long before October 7, 2023, and continues in the ashes of what was once our home. The world’s ceasefire is a fabricated pause in our endless torment. The world seeks its own resolution, a quick fix to soothe the conscience, but for us, the ceasefire is just another fleeting moment in a long history of erasure.
Before the war, Sheikh Ijleen wasn’t just my neighborhood—it was a universe unto itself.
It was the place where my family planted grapevines and fig trees for centuries. It was where I learned to walk among the grapevines, where I came of age. My grandfather’s grave was there, and so were the faces of neighbors whose kindness I remember. These were not just landmarks; they were the thread that wove my sense of self. Today, Sheikh Ijleen exists only in my memory. What was once my home is now nothing but ruins.
The bombs didn’t just explode the buildings there; they also erased the essence of who we were. The IOF didn’t only destroy our homes—they declared our memories illegal. They took my street, my family’s lands, and even the cemetery where my ancestors rest, and they turned it all into a “military zone.”
Now, the very place that held my history and my identity is lost, buried beneath layers of rubble and cold, indifferent military control. The trees that once shielded us from the summer sun are now crushed and their roots are severed. My room, where the setting sun used to paint the walls with golden hues, no longer exists. It is not just the destruction of a place; it is the destruction of memory, of home, of family, and of history.
This erasure is not a mere side effect of war; it is a calculated effort to sever the bonds between people and their land, to strip us of our identity so that we become faceless, nameless victims in the global narrative. The world has never asked for our story before, and now it wants to remember us only as casualties and numbers.
Gaza’s true story is lost in the rubble, overshadowed by the broader political calculations that govern its existence.
Our suffering is made digestible for the international audience, while the deeper, more profound losses are hidden beneath the surface. Sheikh Ijleen is gone, but it lives in my memory, and it is a memory I refuse to let die.
The false resolution of the ceasefire
As the world celebrates the ceasefire, we are left to question its meaning. What does it truly signify for us in Gaza?
It is not an end to the war; it is simply a temporary lull in the violence.
It does not undo the devastation, nor does it heal the wounds inflicted on us.
A ceasefire is nothing more than a global performance, a signal that the world has done enough to appease its own conscience.
But for us, it is nothing more than an intermission in an endless tragedy.
When the bombs stop, the trauma does not fade.
The streets still lie in ruins. The poisoned water still courses through our bodies, and the toxic memories of the bombings linger like an invisible disease.
We don’t return to normal—we adapt to a new kind of existence, one that is born from the wreckage of our past and the uncertainty of our future.
A ceasefire does not undo the loss of homes, of lives, of family members. It does not bring back what has been destroyed. It does not restore dignity, nor does it heal the wounds of displacement.
For the world, a ceasefire is the end of the story, the resolution that allows the audience to turn the page. But for us, it is just another silence, another chapter in a story that never truly ends. The bombs may stop, but the wounds they leave behind will continue to bleed.
And the silence that follows is not peace—it is the deafening quiet of lives left in limbo, waiting for the next round of violence to begin.
The international community reduces Gaza to an event: a spectacle of suffering consumed in headlines and sound bites as if our lives are nothing more than a tragic narrative with a predictable plot. Gaza has become a stage, where every tragedy follows the same story line—suffering, climax, and resolution. We are portrayed as either heroes, martyrs, symbols of resistance, or victims of oppression. Yet, the truth is far more complicated.
Our pain is reduced to symbols, our suffering treated as an image rather than the brutal reality of our lives. Behind every headline is a human being—living through the unimaginable. The headline shows the fire without showing people who are burning behind them.
We refuse to be erased
Even as the world turns away, Gaza refuses to be forgotten.
My neighborhood, Sheikh Ijleen, may no longer exist in the physical world, but it lives in my memory.
The streets I ran through, the fig trees that once grew in my yard, the faces of my neighbors—they are etched in my mind, and the sunset over the sea from my window is as vivid as ever. I refuse to let them be erased.
From Cairo, I hear the hum of civilian planes, and it pulls me back to the roar of F-16s—the only kind of planes I knew before I left Gaza.
The bombing may stop, but the sounds of destruction will always be with us, echoing through our thoughts.
And then they speak of a “humanitarian pause.” How ironic—how hollow—to call it a “humanitarian pause” when we have lived through the very core of inhumanity.
How can the world call it a pause when our humanity has been shattered, when our homes, our memories, and our very existence have been systematically erased?
How can the world declare a pause when we are left to pick up the pieces of a life that no longer exists, to live with the haunting residue of what was once ours?
The bloodshed may stop, but the stains will never leave our hands. The bodies may be cleared from the streets, but the images will never leave our minds. The world will move on, thinking they have fixed the problem with a ceasefire, but for us, it is just another lie in a long history of indifference.
Gaza is not a problem that can be solved with a pause—it is a wound that will never heal.
So now that a ceasefire has been declared and the world celebrates, remember this: the blood may no longer stain the streets, but it will stain our memories. The bombing may have stopped, but we still hear it in our ears. The world may think it’s over, but for us, it is a continuous nightmare and a burden of existence.
 
Ahmed Ahmed and Ruwaida Kamal Amer
It is a pattern with which Gazans are painfully familiar: as reports of an imminent ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hamas began swirling earlier this week, the Israeli military unleashed hell on the besieged Strip, killing at least 62 Palestinians in the past 24 hours.
Among the latest victims was 25-year-old activist and children’s entertainer Ahmed Al-Shawa, who was killed along with several of his colleagues in an airstrike on Gaza City’s Al-Daraj neighborhood. Al-Shawa was known among Palestinians in the Strip as “the smile ambassador” for his sense of humor, energy, kind-heartedness, and passion for his work: bringing joy to Gaza’s children despite the harsh conditions of the ongoing genocide.
Rajab Al-Rifi, a neighbor and colleague of Al-Shawa’s, is unable to come to terms with the loss of his friend. Just two days earlier, on Jan. 12, they had put on an entertainment show together for dozens of displaced children. They had discussed their hopes that a ceasefire would enable them to expand their work, and planned a series of additional activities to help children cope with their trauma, including mental health workshops.
Al-Rifi explained that Al-Shawa was loved by everyone around him due to his generosity. “He sometimes put on three or four shows in one day for hundreds of children,” Al-Rifi told +972. “Every Wednesday since the beginning of genocide, he would do a show by himself in Gaza City’s Municipal Park, where dozens of people have sought refuge. He aimed to put smiles on children’s faces despite their ongoing trauma.”
Tragically, Al-Shawa was killed as he was on his way to join colleagues for an event at a makeshift tent camp in central Gaza City. His death has left a deep sense of grief among the people of Gaza, especially those who knew him. “He was a source of strength and hope to his colleagues, friends, and children,” Al-Rifi said. “What did he do to deserve being killed like this?”
Despite Al-Rifi’s earlier optimism about an imminent ceasefire, he now fears for his own safety and has canceled planned activities due to the intensification of Israeli attacks. “Anyone in Gaza could be a target,” he said. “I fear I could be next.”
‘I dream of the moment I will meet my children again’
Despite the relentless Israeli bombings across the Gaza Strip, many Palestinians remain cautiously optimistic that this time a ceasefire could hold. In some tent camps, displaced residents were already celebrating in the belief that they might soon return home — even as their houses lie in ruins — and reunite with family members from whom they have been separated.
Laila Al-Masri, 55, who fled the Israeli army’s assault on the northern city of Beit Lahiya two months ago, now resides in a makeshift tent in Gaza City’s Al-Yarmouk Stadium. She remains desperately hopeful for the moment she can return to her house and finally bury two of her three sons, who were killed in an Israeli airstrike in November 2024 and whose bodies remain trapped under the rubble of their home. Her remaining son and daughter are displaced in the southern part of the Strip.
“I lost two of my sons, and I pray to God day and night for this ceasefire to succeed before I lose any more loved ones,” she told +972. “I can accept living in a tent on the ruins of my house, as long as we are no longer at risk of being killed at any moment.”
Despite the unimaginable losses, Al-Masri remains cautiously hopeful about the future. “I believe that, in the coming days, we will be able to return to our homes, access food and clean water, and see our children wearing warm clothes and returning to their studies,” she said. “No one can truly understand the pain we have been enduring — the fear, the starvation, the sleepless nights in the cold. A ceasefire would give us the chance to rebuild our lives and start over.”
This sense of optimism is shared by Salem Habib, a 45-year-old from Jabalia refugee camp who has been struggling with the severe hardships of his displacement in the so-called “humanitarian zone” of Al-Mawasi, near Khan Younis in southern Gaza. “I am very optimistic about the success of the truce,” he said. “I haven’t slept while thinking about that moment.”
For over a year, Habib has been separated from his three sons and other relatives who remained in the north of the Strip when he evacuated southward with his wife and daughters at the start of the war. “My eldest son Ahmed was wounded and in a difficult condition,” Habib recounted. “I used to talk to him every day, saying ‘You have to be strong and endure the pain so we can meet again.’”
The thought of losing his sons has consumed Habib. “This was my great fear: that I would lose one of them and return to the north only to not see them alive,” he said. “That is why I await the [final] ceasefire announcement with great patience. I dream of the moment when I will meet my children and grandchildren again.”
Life in the displacement camp, far from Habib’s neighborhood and community, has been extremely difficult, and he is desperate to return home. “If I find it in ruins, I will put up a tent and live there anyway,” he said, adding that he has already begun sorting through his belongings in preparation. “We are all waiting for the moment when we will be able to rest from this ongoing nightmare of bombing, killing, and hunger.”
‘What will be left of our lives?’
But not everyone is so optimistic about the future. Momen Ashraf, 35, who asked to use a pseudonym for safety reasons, is skeptical of the reports of a deal. “Every time there’s talk of a ceasefire, the situation gets worse,” he said. “It’s as if the Israeli forces don’t want anyone left alive in Gaza.”
Ashraf ran an accessories shop next to his house on western Gaza City’s Tal Al-Hawa Street, but he and his family were forced to abandon both under intense bombardment in the first days of the war. In late October 2023, shortly after they had evacuated, their house was bombed.
They were subsequently displaced four more times to various temporary shelters, and are now living in a relative’s house on Gaza City’s Al-Sahaba Street. Ashraf currently operates a stall selling canned food to make a living for his family.
“Our life before the war was not perfect due to the siege and bad economic situation in Gaza, but it was a dream compared to what we’ve been through over the past year,” Ashraf said. “Thirteen of my relatives were killed, and my 6-year-old son was wounded two weeks ago. My home and livelihood were destroyed — for what?”
Ashraf believes that Hamas bears some responsibility for giving Israel an excuse to launch its genocidal war on Gaza after the October 7 attack, with innocent Palestinians forced to pay the price. “Israel has been killing us since 1948, but the surprise attack of October 7 gave them a reason to kill more,” he said.
“Israeli forces killed our loved ones and destroyed our homes, schools, streets, belongings, and beautiful memories,” Ashraf continued. “Most people in Gaza want to live a normal life with peace, we are tired of loss, humiliation, starvation, and displacement. How many lives must be taken before this ends?”
For Ashraf, like many others in Gaza, the announcement of a ceasefire offers little hope for healing and reconstruction in the Strip. “Even if the ceasefire is real, we will need years to recover from what we’ve endured,” he said. “And even then, what will be left of our lives? If I survive this, I will do everything I can to leave Gaza and start over. I don’t believe that anyone cares about us, even the Palestinian factions.”
‘I know my house was badly damaged. I can make do’
Saeed Al-Akhras, a 32-year-old Arabic teacher from Gaza City who was displaced to Al-Mawasi, is eager for the ceasefire to hold so he can go back to teaching and reunite with his students. “I will return to the north on the first day of the ceasefire,” he told +972. “I will return to my neighborhood and set up a tent to teach the students there. I miss my students — I want their noise to return to my life.
“I haven’t slept since we started getting the news reports about the deal,” he continued. “I was forced to flee the north because of my fear for the safety of my three children, and I feel that our return is very close. I hope that the deal will succeed. We are tired and need the war to end so we can return to the north.”
While many of the displaced are waiting to go back to their cities and neighborhoods in northern Gaza, 29-year-old Narmin Kassab is desperate for the ceasefire to begin so she can return to the southern city of Rafah — though she knows that this may take time. Kassab had to flee Rafah in May when the Israeli army invaded the city and destroyed her neighborhood of Tel As-Sultan, forcing her to take refuge in a displacement camp in Deir Al-Balah.
“We know that when the war ends our homes will not be returned to us, but at least we will no longer hear the sound of bombing and news about more victims,” she said. “I won’t go to Rafah immediately; we will stay in the camp because Tel As-Sultan was completely destroyed and there is no infrastructure, and most importantly no water.”
Jawaher Obaid, who is currently residing in a tent in Al-Mawasi, is waiting to return to her home in Gaza City’s Sheikh Radwan neighborhood and reunite with her daughters who remained there when she fled with her son Walid. But Walid will not be with her: he was killed in an Israeli airstrike last February.
“I do not know how I will meet my daughters without having their brother Walid with me,” she told +972. “I will be forced to come to the south often to visit my son’s grave. I will not leave him alone here.”
And when she returns north, she is not planning to take anything from the tent camp with her. “The tent and everything in it reminds me of the worst days of my life,” she explained. “I miss my daughters a lot, and I miss my house. I know it was badly damaged but it is still standing; I can make do and live in it.”

No comments:

Post a Comment